The Planning Commission discussed relaxing the City’s requirements for the size of attached garages for single-family homes at its June 1, 2021 meeting. Currently, the square footage of attached garages is limited to 50% of the home’s footprint for homes on less than one-half acre, 60% for homes on one-half to just under one acre, and 70% on homes on one acre or larger lots.
This has become an issue because developers are finding a demand from home buyers for garages that can accommodate their recreational vehicles or motor homes in addition to their cars. So, this is also creating a second issue, garage height. Currently, Ivins does not allow an attached garage to be higher than the home. So, we are seeing new one-story homes being built higher than they would be normally, to match the extra garage height needed. You can decide for yourself if that’s aesthetically pleasing or not. The home buyers appear content.
Commissioners were mixed on whether to change the current requirement. Some suggested just two tiers: 60% garage area for lots under one acre and 70% for more than an acre. They discussed possibly adding a maximum garage size. And Commissioner Anderson commented that the key is to ensure that the home plus garage still looks like a home and not a home attached to a commercial structure. In other words, keep everything on a human scale.
In a way, the discussion is mute for a lot of single-family development. The State has now eliminated the ability for cities to regulate many building design elements, including building color, for one- and two-family homes. However, if a developer of a subdivision enters into a development agreement with the City, that agreement can include design element requirements. Development agreements typically come into play when developers look for density bonuses. And HOAs can regulate design elements, including garage size, in their CC&Rs.
This discussion will be continued at the next meeting.
Note: Please let me know if I have misunderstood anything in this discussion. Also, please share your comments and tell me about other Ivins issues I have not addressed in recent posts. CONTACT ME
Recent “Development” posts
- How To Think About Rezone ProposalsPDF 📄A proposed zone change is on the City Council’s agenda for the March 6th meeting and there will be a public hearing on this issue (City Hall, 85 N Main Street, meeting starts at 5:30pm). The requested change complies with the Land Use Map. However, the request is for the highest density allowed in…
- Affordable Housing Off Hwy 91?PDF 📄The Utah Trust Lands Administration (SITLA) is looking for development proposals that “offer solutions to solve the housing crisis” on a 40-acre parcel of land in Ivins just off Hwy 91. Proposals must contain a plan to help provide affordable housing with an emphasis on the Governor’s goal of providing single detached homes in…
- Balancing Benefits for Residents & DevelopersPDF 📄When the Hidden Spring RV Resort on Hwy 91 (between Main Street and 200 W) was first proposed years ago, the Planning Commission and City Council crafted thoughtful code requirements to ensure it would truly be a “resort,” not just another RV park. These included landscaping to screen the resort from the road, concrete…
- Finally… A New General PlanPDF 📄 The 2024 Ivins City General Plan was approved in November 2024. It is the primary guiding document and the principal tool to be used to create the future of Ivins. It tells the story of what Ivins was, is and ought to become through thoughtful and careful planning based on the vision, values,…
- Building Permit UpdatePDF 📄Singlefamily permit activity averaged just 62 homes a month in the past twelve months. By comparison, just three years ago singlefamily permits were averaging over 200 homes a month. Multifamily permit activity is another story. And the trend is also misleading. There has been very little “traditional” multifamily permit activity in Ivins in the…